Summary
The goal of every invoicing process is to collect the payment from the customer. But receipt of the cash isn’t always the last step in the process. Discrepancies between invoice amounts and actual payments often prolong the order-to-cash process for weeks after the collection is made. Cash application is a common source of frustration for finance teams, leading to reconciliation nightmares and skewed financial reporting. Understanding the root causes of these mismatches is
1. Mid-Cycle Plan Changes Create Proration Puzzles
When a customer upgrades or downgrades their subscription partway through a billing period, your system must calculate prorated amounts for both the old and new plans. If these adjustments aren’t clearly itemized on the invoice or if there’s a sync delay between your billing and ERP systems, customers may get confused and pay an incorrect amount, leading to a mismatch that requires manual investigation.
2. Payment Processor Fees Take a Hidden Bite
Third-party payment processors like Stripe or Adyen deduct their fees directly from the customer’s payment before the funds ever reach your bank account. This means a $1,000 invoice might result in a $971 deposit. This gap, which can also include currency conversion costs, must be accounted for separately to avoid the appearance of a partial payment and to accurately track processing expenses.
3. Partial Payments Leave Unapplied Cash in Limbo
A customer might intentionally make a partial payment to dispute a specific line item, such as usage-based overage charges. This leaves a portion of the invoice open and creates ‘unapplied cash’ on your books. This not only complicates cash flow reporting and inflates Days Sales Outstanding (DSO) but can also distort key metrics like MRR if not properly tracked.
4.System Sync Delays Create Phantom Reconciliation Issues
A lack of real-time data synchronization between your payment gateway and your ERP is a frequent culprit for mismatches. For instance, a payment might be successfully processed in your billing system but fail to update in your accounting software for hours or even days. This timing gap creates the illusion of unapplied cash, delaying the month-end close and sending finance teams on a hunt for problems that don’t truly exist.
5. Customer Overpayments Cause Unnecessary Work
While it may seem like a good problem to have, customer overpayments create significant administrative burdens. Whether from a duplicate bank transfer after a credit card failure or a bulk payment without specific invoice references, this excess cash doesn’t automatically apply anywhere. Your finance team must then spend valuable time manually investigating the source and either refunding the customer or applying it to future invoices.
6. Global Operations Introduce Tax and Currency Variables
For SaaS companies operating internationally, cross-border transactions add layers of complexity. Fluctuations in foreign exchange (FX) rates between the invoice date and payment date can cause discrepancies. Furthermore, miscalculated VAT/GST or unexpected wire transfer fees deducted by intermediary banks can result in a final settlement that is less than the original invoice amount.
7. Unresolved Customer Disputes Delay Cash Flow
If a customer withholds payment due to a dispute over service credits or contested charges, it creates a direct and often prolonged payment mismatch. Without a clear and efficient workflow for managing these disputes, invoices can remain unpaid for extended periods. This not only strains customer relationships but also negatively impacts cash flow and inflates accounts receivable aging.
Pro-Tips
Tip: Automate Your Financial Tech Stack
Ensure your billing platform, payment processor, and ERP system are tightly integrated and sync data in real time. This eliminates manual data entry and reduces the timing gaps that lead to reconciliation errors.
Tip: Prioritize Invoice Clarity
Make your invoices impossible to misunderstand. Clearly itemize all charges, especially prorations, usage fees, taxes, and any applied credits. The clearer the invoice, the less likely a customer is to dispute it or pay the wrong amount.
Tip: Establish a Formal Dispute Workflow
Don’t let payment disputes linger in email chains. Implement a structured process with clear steps for logging, investigating, and resolving customer billing issues, including the timely issuance of credit memos when necessary.
Conclusion
Reconciling payments and invoices is a critical financial function that directly impacts the accuracy of your SaaS metrics. By understanding common pitfalls like processor fees, system delays, and proration confusion, you can implement more robust processes. To gain a deeper understanding of these challenges and the strategic solutions, explore the complete article.
See Ordway’s accounts receivable automation software in action.
Learn More about SaaS Metrics
